| Finalist | |
| Name | Lydia DeVincent |
| Father | |
| Mother | Piper Davidson |
| High School | Orrville |
| HS Grad Year | 2016 |
| College | University of Akron |
| Major | Mechanical Engineering |
| Finalist | |
| Name | Thomas DiFilippo |
| Father | Alex DiFilippo |
| Mother | Susan DiFilippo |
| High School | Wooster |
| HS Grad Year | 2014 |
| College | Miami of Ohio University |
| Major | Biology |
| Finalist | |
| Name | Audra Gill |
| Father | William Gill |
| Mother | Debra Gill |
| High School | Northwestern |
| HS Grad Year | 2016 |
| College | Bowling Green State University |
| Major | Health Administration and International Business |
| Finalist | |
| Name | Zoe Bates |
| Father | Jim Bates |
| Mother | Linda Bates |
| High School | Smithville |
| HS Grad Year | 2016 |
| College | Kent State University |
| Major | Biology – Pre Med |
