| Finalist | |
| Name | Carly vanTol |
| Father | Kim vanTol |
| Mother | Trish vanTol |
| High School | Triway |
| HS Grad Year | 2013 |
| College | University of Akron |
| Major | B.S. in Nursing |
| Finalist | |
| Name | Thomas DiFilippo |
| Father | Alex DiFilippo |
| Mother | Susan DiFilippo |
| High School | Wooster |
| HS Grad Year | 2014 |
| College | Miami of Ohio University |
| Major | Biology |
| Finalist | |
| Name | Alyson Schar |
| Father | Jeff Schar |
| Mother | Lynette Schar |
| High School | Smithville |
| HS Grad Year | 2014 |
| College | Malone University |
| Major | Middle Childhood Education |
| Finalist | |
| Name | Dreya Holmes |
| Father | Donna Lee Holmes |
| Mother | Jerome Holmes |
| High School | Wooster |
| HS Grad Year | 2014 |
| College | Kent State University |
| Major | Electron Media Production |
