| Finalist | |
| Name | Kaitlyn Martin |
| Father | Mark Martin |
| Mother | Shelly Martin |
| High School | Triway |
| HS Grad Year | 2013 |
| College | Ashland University |
| College Grad Year | 2017 |
| Medicine | Middle Grades Education |
| Finalist | |
| Name | Alexandria Massaro |
| Father | Steven Massaro |
| Mother | Kristen Massaro |
| High School | Smithville |
| HS Grad Year | 2012 |
| College | University of Akron |
| College Grad Year | 2016 |
| Medicine | Education |
| Finalist | |
| Name | Erin Johnson |
| Father | Erik Johnson |
| Mother | Rose Johnson |
| High School | Wooster |
| HS Grad Year | 2013 |
| College | Cedarville University |
| College Grad Year | 2017 |
| Medicine | Engineering |
| Finalist | |
| Name | Lauren Yacapraro |
| Father | Tony Yacapraro |
| Mother | Michelle Yacapraro |
| High School | Triway |
| HS Grad Year | 2012 |
| College | Bowling Green State University |
| College Grad Year | 2016 |
| Medicine | Dietetics |
